Theory explainer
BOD Problems — FE/PE Civil Exam Worked Examples
Biochemical oxygen demand is the exam's way of asking how strong a waste is and how fast it decays. Nearly every BOD question is one of five moves: run the first-order equation forward to BODt, read it off a dilution bottle, run it backwards to ultimate BOD, correct the rate constant for temperature, or mix two streams. Learn the five moves and the two bases, and the topic is closed.
Last reviewed: 2026-10-29. Every worked number below was independently re-solved; steps are shown in full.
The first-order BOD equation, in both bases
Microbes consume biodegradable matter at a rate proportional to how much is left, which gives first-order decay: the BOD remaining after time t is L0e−kt, and the BOD exerted by time t is the complement, y = L0(1 − e−kt). The same equation in base 10 is y = L0(1 − 10−Kt), with k = 2.303K. The exam hands you one base and expects you to notice which: a base-10 K dropped into the base-e formula understates the decay by a factor of 2.303 in the exponent, and the answer comes out wrong with no visible warning. At the standard k = 0.23 day−1 (base e, 20°C), BOD5 is about 0.68 × L0 — a useful sanity check, since roughly two-thirds of the ultimate demand is exerted in five days at that rate.
The dilution bottle test, with the seeded-blank correction
The 5-day test dilutes a small sample into a 300 mL bottle of dilution water, incubates it at 20°C for five days, and measures the dissolved-oxygen (DO) drop. The sample's BOD5 is the DO depletion times the dilution factor, bottle volume divided by sample volume. Two validity rules guard the test: the depletion should be at least about 2 mg/L (otherwise the drop is noise), and at least about 2 mg/L of DO should remain at the end (otherwise the bottle went anaerobic and the result is censored). When the dilution water is seeded with microbes, the seed itself consumes oxygen, so the blank bottle's depletion — scaled by the fraction of dilution water in the sample bottle — is subtracted first. Skipping that correction overstates the sample's BOD, and the exam includes the blank data precisely to catch candidates who ignore it.
Temperature correction: the constant moves, L0 does not
The rate constant depends on temperature through KT = K20 × θT−20, with θ commonly 1.047. Warmer water decays faster, colder water slower — but the ultimate BOD is a property of the waste, not the weather, so L0 is identical at 10°C and 30°C. The correction applies to the constant in whichever base you are working in; if the question gives K in base 10 and the equation you need is base e, correct first, then multiply by 2.303. A common exam variant asks for BOD5 at a new temperature given only the 20°C constant and L0: correct the constant, then run the first-order equation at the new constant.
Mixing: the flow-weighted average
When a waste stream joins a river, the mixed BOD at the mixing point is the flow-weighted average: BODmix = (Qr × BODr + Qw × BODw) / (Qr + Qw). It assumes immediate, complete mixing and uses the flows and BODs at the mixing point — decay after mixing is a separate, downstream calculation (the oxygen-sag problem, covered on the DO Sag page). The usual trap is averaging the two BODs without the flows, or weighting by the wrong flow. Note the units: flows must share a unit (cfs with cfs, MGD with MGD) — the ratio is what matters, so a consistent pair works even without converting to a common discharge unit.
Worked problem 1 \(BOD_{5}\) from ultimate BOD (FE pace)
Given: a wastewater sample has an ultimate BOD \(L_{0} = 320\,\text{mg}/\text{L}\) and a first-order rate constant \(k = 0.25\,\text{day}\)−1 (base e). Find \(BOD_{5}\).
Solution:
- The constant is base e, so use \(y = L_{0} (1 - e^{-kt})\) with \(t = 5\) days.
- Exponent: kt = \(0.25 \times 5 = 1.25\), so e−1.25 = 0.2865.
- \(BOD_{5} = 320 \times (1 - 0.2865) = 320 \times 0.7135\) = 228.3 \(\frac{\text{mg}}{L}\).
Answer: \(BOD_{5} \approx 228\,\text{mg}/\text{L}\). Sanity check: about 71% of the ultimate demand exerted in five days is plausible at this rate — faster than the 68% rule-of-thumb at \(k = 0.23\), as it should be for a larger k. Trap note: an answer near 160 \(\frac{\text{mg}}{L}\) would come from halving \(L_{0}\) — the linear assumption the exam plants as a distractor.
Worked problem 2 Dilution bottle test with a seeded blank (FE pace)
Given: a 10 mL sample is diluted to 300 mL in seeded dilution water and incubated 5 days at 20°C. The sample bottle's DO falls from 8.6 to 3.1 \(\frac{\text{mg}}{L}\); the seeded blank bottle's DO falls from 8.7 to 8.4 \(\frac{\text{mg}}{L}\). Find the sample'\(s BOD_{5}\).
Solution:
- Sample depletion = \(8.6 - 3.1 = 5.5\,\text{mg}/\text{L}\). Blank depletion = \(8.7 - 8.4 = 0.3\,\text{mg}/\text{L}\).
- The sample bottle is \(\frac{290}{300}\) dilution water, so the blank correction is \(0.3 \times (\frac{290}{300}) = 0.29\,\text{mg}/\text{L}\).
- Net depletion = \(5.5 - 0.29 = 5.21\,\text{mg}/\text{L}\). Dilution factor = \(\frac{300}{10} = 30\).
- \(BOD_{5} = 5.21 \times 30\) = 156.3 \(\frac{\text{mg}}{L}\).
Answer: \(BOD_{5} \approx 156\,\text{mg}/\text{L}\). Validity check: depletion 5.5 \(\frac{\text{mg}}{L}\) exceeds the ~2 \(\frac{\text{mg}}{L}\) minimum, and 3.1 \(\frac{\text{mg}}{L}\) of DO remains, above the ~2 \(\frac{\text{mg}}{L}\) floor — the test is valid. Trap note: ignoring the blank gives \(5.5 \times 30 = 165\,\text{mg}/\text{L}\), the planted distractor; ignoring the dilution factor entirely gives 5.2 \(\frac{\text{mg}}{L}\), which is the bottle's depletion, not the sample's BOD.
Worked problem 3 Back-solving \(L_{0}\) and the BOD remaining (FE pace)
Given: a wastewater has \(BOD_{5} = 180\,\text{mg}/\text{L}\) with a rate constant \(k = 0.15\,\text{day}\)−1 (base e). Find the ultimate BOD and the BOD remaining after 5 days.
Solution:
- Rearrange the equation: \(L_{0} = \frac{BOD_{5}}{(1 - e^{-kt})} = \frac{180}{(1 - e^{-0.75})}\).
- e−0.75 = 0.4724, so \(L_{0} = \frac{180}{0.5276}\) = 341.1 \(\frac{\text{mg}}{L}\).
- BOD remaining after 5 days = \(L_{0} - BOD_{5} = 341.1 - 180\) = 161.1 \(\frac{\text{mg}}{L}\) (equivalently \(L_{0} e\)−0.75 = \(341.1 \times 0.4724 = 161.1\,\text{mg}/\text{L}\)).
Answer: ultimate BOD ≈ 341 \(\frac{\text{mg}}{L}\); BOD remaining after 5 days ≈ 161 \(\frac{\text{mg}}{L}\). Trap note: the stem asks for what is left, not what was exerted — reporting 180 \(\frac{\text{mg}}{L}\) answers the wrong quantity. Also note the ratio: at this slower rate only about 53% of the ultimate demand is exerted in five days, well below the 68% rule-of-thumb at \(k = 0.23\).
Worked problem 4 Temperature correction plus base conversion (PE pace)
Given: a waste has ultimate BOD \(L_{0} = 300\,\text{mg}/\text{L}\) and a base-10 rate constant \(K_{20} = 0.10\,\text{day}\)−1 at 20°C. Take \(\theta = 1.047\). Find the base-e rate constant at 30°C and the \(BOD_{5}\) at 30°C.
Solution:
- Correct the constant to 30°C in base 10: \(K_{30} = 0.10 \times 1.047^{10} = 0.10 \times 1.582 = 0.1583\,\text{day}\)−1.
- Convert to base e: \(k_{30} = 2.303 \times 0.1583\) = 0.365 day−1.
- \(BOD_{5}\) at \(30^{\circ} C = 300 \times (1 - e^{-0.365 \times 5}) = 300 \times (1 - e^{-1.82}) = 300 \times (1 - 0.1620)\) = 251.5 \(\frac{\text{mg}}{L}\).
Answer: \(k_{30} \approx 0.365\,\text{day}\)−1 (base e); \(BOD_{5}\) at \(30^{\circ} C \approx 252\,\text{mg}/\text{L}\). Trap note: \(L_{0}\) stays 300 \(\frac{\text{mg}}{L}\) — temperature changes the rate, not the ultimate demand. Using the uncorrected \(K_{20} \text{in}\) the base-e formula (0.10 instead of 0.365) would give only about 118 \(\frac{\text{mg}}{L}\), less than half the correct value.
Worked problem 5 Mixed BOD below an outfall (FE pace)
Given: a waste stream of 5 cfs with BOD 240 \(\frac{\text{mg}}{L}\) joins a river flowing at 50 cfs with BOD 4 \(\frac{\text{mg}}{L}\). Assume immediate, complete mixing. Find the mixed BOD just below the outfall.
Solution:
- Flow-weighted average: \(BOD_{mix} = \frac{(50 \times 4 + 5 \times 240)}{(50 + 5)} = \frac{(200 + 1200)}{55}\).
- \(BOD_{mix} = \frac{1400}{55}\) = 25.45 \(\frac{\text{mg}}{L}\).
Answer: mixed BOD ≈ 25 \(\frac{\text{mg}}{L}\) just below the outfall. Trap note: the simple average of 4 and 240 is 122 \(\frac{\text{mg}}{L}\) — five times too high, because it ignores that the river carries ten times the waste stream's flow. This mixed value is the \(L_{0}\) that feeds the downstream oxygen-sag calculation on the DO Sag page.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between BOD5 and ultimate BOD?
BOD5 is the oxygen consumed in the standard 5-day test at 20°C — the regulatory workhorse. Ultimate BOD, L0, is the total oxygen that would be consumed if the biodegradable matter were fully oxidised. At k = 0.23 day−1 (base e), BOD5 is about 68% of L0, so the two are never interchangeable.
How do base-e and base-10 BOD rate constants relate?
k (base e) = 2.303 × K (base 10). The two forms are y = L0(1 − e−kt) and y = L0(1 − 10−Kt). Using a base-10 K in the base-e formula — or the reverse — is a quiet, total error, so check which base the question gives before substituting.
How is BOD5 found from a dilution bottle test?
Multiply the dissolved-oxygen depletion by the dilution factor (bottle volume divided by sample volume). With seeded dilution water, first subtract the seeded blank's depletion scaled by the fraction of dilution water in the bottle. A valid test needs at least about 2 mg/L of depletion and at least about 2 mg/L of dissolved oxygen remaining at the end.
How is the BOD rate constant corrected for temperature?
KT = K20 × θT−20, with θ commonly 1.047. The ultimate BOD does not change with temperature — only the rate at which it is exerted does. Apply the correction in the base you are working in, then convert bases with k = 2.303K if the equation needs the other base.
How is the BOD of a mixed stream calculated?
By a flow-weighted average: BODmix = (Qr × BODr + Qw × BODw) / (Qr + Qw), with r the receiving stream and w the waste stream. It assumes immediate, complete mixing, and it uses the flows and BODs at the mixing point — not downstream values after decay has begun.
What is BOD remaining, and how does it differ from BOD exerted?
BOD exerted by time t is y = L0(1 − e−kt); BOD remaining (unexerted) is L0 − y = L0e−kt. A stem asking for what is left after 5 days wants the remaining term, not the exerted term — swapping them is the most common one-word misread on this topic.
Free FE/PE flashcards + study tips, by email
Join the Water Resources Hub email list and get the free 40 water-resources flashcards (PDF + Anki) straight away, then study tips and practice problems by email. Email address only — no spam, unsubscribe any time.