Theory explainer
Rankine Earth Pressure Problems — FE/PE Civil Exam Worked Examples
A retaining wall feels a horizontal push that grows with depth, and nearly every exam question about it is one of five moves: pick the right coefficient (at-rest, active, or passive), add a surcharge block, split soil from water at a water table, cut off the tension zone in cohesive backfill, or compute the passive resistance in front of the wall. Learn the five moves and the ordering Ka < K0 < Kp, and the topic is closed.
Last reviewed: 2026-10-30. Every worked number below was independently re-solved; steps are shown in full.
The three states, and the ordering that checks your work
Rankine theory gives the two limiting states for a smooth vertical wall with horizontal backfill: the active state, reached when the wall moves away and the soil mass stretches to failure, and the passive state, reached when the wall is pushed into the soil and compresses it to failure. Between them sits the at-rest state, where the wall does not move at all. The ordering Ka < K0 < Kp always holds, and it is a free sanity check on every problem: for φ = 30°, Ka = 1/3, K0 = 1/2, and Kp = 3. If a computed "active" thrust ever exceeds the at-rest thrust for the same wall, the wrong coefficient went in. Rankine's simple coefficients assume a smooth wall and level backfill, so the pressure acts horizontally; wall friction, a battered back, or an inclined backfill calls for Coulomb's method or Rankine's inclined form instead.
Surcharge: a rectangle, not extra soil
A uniform surcharge q on the backfill surface raises the vertical stress by q at every depth, so it adds a constant horizontal pressure K·q from top to bottom — a rectangular block on the pressure diagram, with thrust K·q·H acting at H/2 above the base. The trap is modelling the surcharge as an equivalent extra depth of soil, which makes its pressure grow with depth instead of staying constant, or forgetting it entirely because it does not appear in the triangular soil diagram. When soil and surcharge act together, take moments about the base to locate the combined resultant; averaging the two heights (H/3 and H/2) is not the same thing.
Water table: split the problem in two
Below the water table, the soil pressure runs on effective stress: replace the saturated unit weight with the submerged weight γ′ = γsat − γw (γw = 62.4 pcf in US units) and apply the Rankine coefficient to that effective stress only. Then add the hydrostatic water pressure γwz as its own triangular diagram, with no coefficient at all. The pressure diagram below the water table is therefore trapezoidal for the soil part plus a triangle for the water, and the total thrust is the sum of the pieces — typically computed as one triangle above the water table, one rectangle and one triangle for the effective soil below it, and one triangle for the water. Applying Ka to the water pressure is the classic error, and it understates the total thrust by a large margin because water pressure is usually the biggest single piece.
Cohesive backfill: the tension crack
In a c–φ soil the Rankine active stress is σa = Kaγz − 2c√Ka, which is negative near the surface — the theory predicts tension, which soil cannot sustain. The zero-pressure depth is zc = 2c/(γ√Ka). If the stem says a tension crack has formed (or asks for the thrust after cracking), the negative zone is dropped entirely and the thrust is the triangle below the crack: Pa = ½Kaγ(H − zc)². Note that the familiar full-height expression ½KaγH² − 2c√Ka·H is the thrust before the crack opens, with the tension zone still counted as negative pressure; once the crack is there, that expression no longer applies, and for deep tension zones it can even go negative — a sign the crack formula is the one wanted, not a sign the arithmetic failed. For saturated clay under undrained conditions (φ = 0), Ka = 1, which simplifies the arithmetic considerably.
Worked problem 1 Active and passive thrust, dry sand (FE pace)
Given: a 15 ft vertical wall retains dry sand with \(\gamma = 120\) pcf and \(\phi = 30^{\circ}\). Find the active thrust per foot of wall and the passive resistance per foot if the same soil were in front of the wall.
Solution:
- Coefficients: \(K_{a} = \tan^{2} (45^{\circ} - 15^{\circ}) = \tan^{2} (30^{\circ}) = \frac{1}{3} = 0.333\); \(K_{p} = \tan^{2} (45^{\circ} + 15^{\circ}) = \tan^{2} (60^{\circ}) = 3.00 (also \frac{1}{K_{a}})\).
- Active thrust: \(P_{a} = \frac{1}{2} \times 0.333 \times 120 \times 15^{2} = 0.5 \times 0.333 \times 120 \times 225\) = 4,500 lbf/ft, acting at \(\frac{15}{3} = 5\,\text{ft}\) above the base.
- Passive resistance: \(P_{p} = \frac{1}{2} \times 3.00 \times 120 \times 15^{2}\) = 40,500 lbf/ft, also at 5 ft above the base.
Answer: \(P_{a} \approx 4500\) lbf/ft; \(P_{p} \approx 40500\) lbf/ft. The nine-fold ratio is the point: passive resistance is \(\frac{K_{p}}{K_{a}} = 9\) times the active thrust for the same wall and soil. Trap note: an active answer near 13,500 lbf/ft comes from using \(K_{0} = 0.5\) or misreading the coefficient — and any "active" value above the at-rest thrust of 6,750 lbf/ft fails the \(K_{a} < K_{0} < K_{p}\) check at once.
Worked problem 2 Surcharge on the backfill (FE pace)
Given: a 12 ft wall retains sand with \(\gamma = 115\) pcf and \(\phi = 32^{\circ}\), carrying a uniform surcharge \(q = 500\,\text{psf}\) on the surface. Find the total active thrust per foot of wall.
Solution:
- \(K_{a} = \tan^{2} (45^{\circ} - 16^{\circ}) = \tan^{2} (29^{\circ}) = 0.307\).
- Soil triangle: \(P_{\text{soil}} = \frac{1}{2} \times 0.307 \times 115 \times 12^{2}\) = 2,544 lbf/ft, acting at \(\frac{12}{3} = 4\,\text{ft}\) above the base.
- Surcharge rectangle: \(P_{q} = K_{a} \times q \times H = 0.307 \times 500 \times 12\) = 1,844 lbf/ft, acting at \(\frac{12}{2} = 6\,\text{ft}\) above the base.
- Total: \(P_{a} = 2544 + 1844\) = 4,388 lbf/ft. Combined height by moments: \(\frac{(2544 \times 4 + 1844 \times 6)}{4388} = \frac{21240}{4388} = 4.84\,\text{ft}\) above the base.
Answer: \(P_{a} \approx 4390\) lbf/ft, acting about 4.8 ft above the base. Trap note: the surcharge block is over 40% of the total thrust here — dropping it is the single biggest error available on this problem. Modelling it as extra soil depth instead of a rectangle gives a triangular block of the wrong shape and the wrong resultant height.
Worked problem 3 Water table in the backfill (PE pace)
Given: an 18 ft wall retains sand \((\phi = 30^{\circ}, so K_{a} = \frac{1}{3})\) with the water table 6 ft below the surface. Above the water table \(\gamma = 120\) pcf; below it \(\gamma_{\text{sat}} = 130\) pcf. Take \(\gamma_{w} = 62.4\) pcf. Find the total lateral thrust per foot of wall and its height above the base.
Solution:
- Submerged weight: \(\gamma' = 130 - 62.4 = 67.6\) pcf. Effective soil pressure at 6 ft: \((\frac{1}{3}) \times 120 \times 6 = 240\,\text{psf}\). At 18 ft: \((\frac{1}{3}) \times (120 \times 6 + 67.6 \times 12) = (\frac{1}{3}) \times 1531.2 = 510.4\,\text{psf}\). Water pressure at 18 ft: \(62.4 \times 12 = 748.8\,\text{psf}\).
- Four force pieces: top triangle \(\frac{1}{2} \times 240 \times 6 = 720\) lbf/ft; middle rectangle \(240 \times 12 = 2880\) lbf/ft; lower soil triangle \(\frac{1}{2} \times (510.4 - 240) \times 12 = 1622\) lbf/ft; water triangle \(\frac{1}{2} \times 748.8 \times 12 = 4493\) lbf/ft.
- Total: \(720 + 2880 + 1622 + 4493\) = 9,715 lbf/ft. Moments about the base (heights 14, 6, 4, 4 ft respectively) give a resultant at 5.33 ft above the base.
Answer: total thrust ≈ 9,720 lbf/ft, acting about 5.3 ft above the base. Note the water triangle alone \((4,493 lbf/\text{ft})\) is the largest single piece — nearly half the total thrust, though still less than the entire dry-soil thrust for this wall \((0.5 \times \frac{1}{3} \times 120 \times 18^{2} = 6480 lbf/\text{ft})\) — that is why drainage behind a retaining wall matters, and why applying \(K_{a}\) to the water pressure (which would cut it to a third) is so dangerous. Trap note: using \(\gamma_{\text{sat}}\) instead of γ′ for the soil below the water table double-counts the water.
Worked problem 4 Cohesive backfill and the tension crack (PE pace)
Given: a 15 ft wall retains c–φ soil with \(c = 400\,\text{psf}\), \(\phi = 20^{\circ}\), \(\gamma = 120\) pcf. A tension crack has formed. Find the active thrust per foot of wall.
Solution:
- \(K_{a} = \tan^{2} (45^{\circ} - 10^{\circ}) = \tan^{2} (35^{\circ}) = 0.490\), so \(\sqrt{K_{a}} = 0.700\).
- Tension-crack depth: \(z_{c} = 2 \frac{c}{(\gamma \sqrt{K_{a}})} = \frac{800}{(120 \times 0.700)} = 9.52\,\text{ft}\) — nearly two-thirds of the wall height is in tension and carries no pressure.
- Thrust below the crack: \(P_{a} = \frac{1}{2} \times 0.490 \times 120 \times (15 - 9.52)^{2} = 0.5 \times 0.490 \times 120 \times 30.03\) = 883 lbf/ft.
Answer: \(P_{a} \approx 880\) lbf/ft. Compare with the cohesionless thrust for the same wall and \(\phi (0.5 \times 0.490 \times 120 \times 225 = 6615 lbf/\text{ft})\): cohesion plus the crack cuts the thrust by nearly 90%. Trap note: the pre-crack expression \(\frac{1}{2} K_{a} \gamma H^{2} - 2 c \sqrt{K_{a}} \cdot H\) gives −1,784 lbf/ft here — a negative thrust is the signal that the crack formula, not the full-height formula, is the one the stem wants. Ignoring cohesion entirely gives 6,615 lbf/ft, the planted distractor.
Worked problem 5 Passive resistance in front of a wall (FE pace)
Given: soil with \(\gamma = 120\) pcf and \(\phi = 30^{\circ}\) is embedded 4 ft in front of a wall. Find the passive resistance per foot of wall.
Solution:
- \(K_{p} = \tan^{2} (45^{\circ} + 15^{\circ}) = 3.00\).
- \(P_{p} = \frac{1}{2} \times 3.00 \times 120 \times 4^{2} = 0.5 \times 3.00 \times 120 \times 16\) = 2,880 lbf/ft, acting at \(\frac{4}{3} = 1.33\,\text{ft}\) above the base of the embedded zone.
Answer: \(P_{p} \approx 2880\) lbf/ft. This is the resistance term in sliding and overturning checks for embedded walls — and the reason a shallow embedment still contributes: passive pressure grows with the square of the embedded depth, so doubling the embedment quadruples the resistance. Trap note: using \(K_{a}\) here gives 320 lbf/ft, a nine-fold underestimate that fails any stability check it feeds into.
Frequently asked questions
How do the Rankine active, at-rest and passive coefficients compare?
Always Ka < K0 < Kp. For a level cohesionless backfill, Ka = tan²(45° − φ/2), K0 = 1 − sin φ (Jaky, normally consolidated soil), and Kp = tan²(45° + φ/2) = 1/Ka. If a computed active thrust ever exceeds the at-rest value, the wrong coefficient has been used.
Where does the resultant of a triangular earth-pressure diagram act?
At H/3 above the base of the wall, where H is the wall height. A uniform surcharge adds a rectangular pressure block Ka·q over the full height, whose resultant acts at H/2 above the base. When both act together, take moments about the base to find the combined resultant height — do not average the two heights.
How is a water table behind a retaining wall handled?
Split the problem: use effective stress for the soil pressure (submerged unit weight γ′ = γsat − γw below the water table, with the Rankine coefficient applied to effective stress only) and add the hydrostatic water pressure γw·z separately, with no coefficient. Water has no K — applying Ka to the water pressure understates the total thrust.
What is a tension crack in cohesive backfill, and how does it change the active thrust?
In cohesive soil the Rankine active stress σa = Kaγz − 2c√Ka is negative near the surface, down to the tension-crack depth zc = 2c/(γ√Ka). Soil cannot sustain tension, so the negative zone is dropped: once a crack has formed, the active thrust is the triangle below the crack, Pa = ½Kaγ(H − zc)², not the full-height formula minus the cohesion term.
When is Rankine theory applicable, and when is Coulomb needed?
Rankine's simple coefficients assume a smooth vertical wall back and a horizontal backfill surface, so the pressure acts horizontally. With wall friction, a battered wall back, or an inclined backfill, the coefficients change and Coulomb's wedge method — or Rankine's inclined-backfill form — is the correct tool. The FE exam's standard Rankine problems use the smooth-wall, level-backfill case unless the stem says otherwise.
Free FE/PE flashcards + study tips, by email
Join the Water Resources Hub email list and get the free 40 water-resources flashcards (PDF + Anki) straight away, then study tips and practice problems by email. Email address only — no spam, unsubscribe any time.