Theory explainer
Sedimentation Problems — FE/PE Civil Exam Worked Examples
Sedimentation is gravity doing the treatment: water moves slowly through a basin, particles heavier than water settle to the bottom, and the clarified water leaves over the weirs. The exam tests the basin with three numbers that use three different dimensions — the surface overflow rate (plan area), the detention time (volume), and the weir loading (weir length) — plus Stokes’ law for the settling velocity of the particle itself. Every problem below is the same idea applied to a different dimension: a particle is removed if it can fall the depth of the basin before the water carries it to the outlet, and the surface overflow rate is the settling velocity a particle needs to do exactly that. Get the dimension right, keep the units straight, and the problem is arithmetic.
Last reviewed: 2026-11-12. Every worked number below was independently re-solved; steps are shown in full.
The surface overflow rate: the one number that sizes the basin
The surface overflow rate (SOR), also called the surface loading rate, is the flow divided by the basin’s plan area: SOR = Q / A. It has the units of a velocity — gallons per day per square foot in US units, metres per day in SI — and it is the settling velocity a particle needs to be removed completely. The reason is geometric: a particle that enters at the surface must fall the full depth of the basin in the time the water takes to travel its length, and that condition reduces exactly to vs ≥ Q/A. Water-treatment sedimentation basins typically run about 800–1,200 gpd/ft² (about 33–49 m/day); primary clarifiers about 600–1,200 gpd/ft². The same ratio answers the sizing question backwards: the area a basin needs is A = Q / vs for the smallest particle to be removed completely, which is Worked Problem 5. The theory, with the treatment-train context, is on the Water Treatment page; this page is where the numbers get worked.
Detention time and the horizontal velocity check
The theoretical detention time is t = V / Q — the volume divided by the flow, in hours. Water-treatment basins typically run about 2–4 hours; a detention time under an hour means the basin is too small for flocculent settling, whatever the overflow rate says, because floc particles grow as they settle and need time as well as area. The second check is the horizontal flow velocity, vh = Q / (W × D), where W × D is the cross-section the water flows through. A particle is removed if it can fall the depth D in the time the water takes to travel the length L — that is, if D/vs ≤ L/vh — and the ratio of the two times is the margin the basin has. Worked Problem 4 runs both checks on the same basin and shows a basin that passes the settling check while failing the weir check, which is the exam’s favourite kind of verdict: the numbers are right and the design is still wrong.
Stokes’ law and the removal rule
Stokes’ law gives the terminal settling velocity of a small spherical particle in laminar flow: vs = g(S − 1)d² / (18ν), where S is the particle’s specific gravity, d its diameter, and ν the water’s kinematic viscosity. It applies only where the flow around the particle is creeping — formally a particle Reynolds number Re = vs × d / ν below about 1, which in water at 20 °C means diameters below roughly 0.1 mm, silt and clay territory. Above that, the real settling velocity falls below the Stokes value and coarse sand needs Newton’s drag law instead, so the exam tests the check, not just the formula: compute vs from Stokes, then compute Re, and only trust the answer if Re is below about 1. The removal rule for discrete (Type I) settling in an ideal basin is η = vs/v0 × 100% for particles slower than the overflow rate, and 100% for particles at or above it. Two consequences follow. First, the minimum diameter removed completely at a given SOR comes from setting vs = v0 and solving for d — Worked Problem 3, where quartz (S = 2.65) and organic particles (S = 1.20) give very different answers at the same overflow rate. Second, cold water settles more slowly: the kinematic viscosity at 5 °C is about 1.52 × 10−6 m²/s against about 1.00 × 10−6 m²/s at 20 °C, so a particle settles about 34% more slowly in winter water — a basin sized for summer removes finer particles in summer than in winter.
Worked problem 1 SOR, detention time and weir loading (FE pace, US units)
Given: a rectangular sedimentation basin is 120 ft long, 40 ft wide and 12 ft deep, and treats 4.0 MGD. The outlet weirs run along both long sides (240 ft total). Find the surface overflow rate, the theoretical detention time and the weir loading, and judge the design.
Solution:
- Plan area: A = 120 × 40 = 4,800 ft². Surface overflow rate: SOR = Q / A = 4,000,000 ÷ 4,800 = 833 gpd/ft² — inside the typical 800–1,200 gpd/ft² range for water treatment.
- Volume: V = 120 × 40 × 12 = 57,600 ft³, and 57,600 × 7.48 gal/ft³ = 430,900 gal (0.431 MG). Detention time: t = V / Q = 0.431 ÷ 4.0 = 0.108 day × 24 = 2.59 h — inside the typical 2–4 h range.
- Weir loading: 4,000,000 gpd ÷ 240 ft = 16,700 gpd/ft — inside the typical 10,000–20,000 gpd/ft range for a clarifier.
Answer: SOR ≈ 833 gpd/ft²; detention time ≈ 2.6 h; weir loading ≈ 16,700 gpd/ft — all three checks pass, a sound basin at this flow. Trap note: the three checks use three different dimensions, and the exam’s distractors are the swaps — dividing the flow by the volume (4,000,000 ÷ 430,900 = 9.28 per day) answers nothing the question asked, and dividing by the weir length when the question asks for the overflow rate gives 16,700 gpd/ft, which is the weir loading wearing the wrong label. The second trap is the gallon conversion: the volume in cubic feet must be multiplied by 7.48 gal/ft³ before it can be divided by a flow in MGD, and a candidate who divides 57,600 ft³ by 4.0 MGD directly gets a detention time of 0.35 hours, which no basin runs.
Worked problem 2 Removal efficiency from the overflow rate (FE pace, SI)
Given: a horizontal-flow sedimentation tank has a surface overflow rate of 17 m³/day/m². What percentage of particles with a settling velocity of 0.10 mm/s is removed, assuming an ideal basin?
Solution:
- Convert the overflow rate to the same units as the settling velocity: v0 = 17 m/day = 17,000 mm ÷ 86,400 s = 0.197 mm/s.
- The particle settles more slowly than the overflow rate (0.10 < 0.197 mm/s), so it is only partly removed: η = vs / v0 × 100% = 0.10 ÷ 0.197 × 100% = 50.8%.
Answer: about 51% of the particles are removed. Trap note: the unit conversion is the whole problem — 17 m/day looks small next to 0.10 mm/s until both are in the same units, and a candidate who compares 17 with 0.10 directly concludes the particle is removed completely, which is the wrong side of the ratio by a factor of 170. The second trap is the direction of the ratio: the efficiency is the particle’s velocity divided by the overflow rate, not the other way round — v0/vs = 197% is not a removal efficiency, it is the arithmetic telling the candidate the ratio is upside down.
Worked problem 3 Stokes’ law and the smallest particle removed (PE pace, SI)
Given: water at 20 °C has a kinematic viscosity of 1.00 × 10−6 m²/s. (a) Find the settling velocity of a 0.10 mm quartz particle (specific gravity 2.65) and check whether Stokes’ law applies. (b) A rectangular sedimentation tank runs at a surface overflow rate of 45 m³/m²/day. Find the minimum diameters of inorganic particles (specific gravity 2.65) and organic particles (specific gravity 1.20) expected to be completely removed.
Solution:
- (a) Stokes’ law: vs = g(S − 1)d² / (18ν) = 9.81 × (2.65 − 1) × (1.0 × 10−4 m)² ÷ (18 × 1.00 × 10−6) = 1.619 × 10−7 ÷ 1.80 × 10−5 = 8.99 × 10−3 m/s, or 8.99 mm/s.
- Check the regime: Re = vs × d / ν = 8.99 × 10−3 × 1.0 × 10−4 ÷ 1.00 × 10−6 = 0.90 — below 1, so Stokes’ law applies and the velocity is trusted.
- (b) The overflow rate in m/s: v0 = 45 ÷ 86,400 = 5.21 × 10−4 m/s. Complete removal needs vs = v0, so d = √(18νv0 / (g(S − 1))).
- Inorganic (S = 2.65): d = √(18 × 1.00 × 10−6 × 5.21 × 10−4 ÷ (9.81 × 1.65)) = √(5.79 × 10−10) = 2.41 × 10−5 m, or 24.1 µm.
- Organic (S = 1.20): d = √(18 × 1.00 × 10−6 × 5.21 × 10−4 ÷ (9.81 × 0.20)) = √(4.78 × 10−9) = 6.91 × 10−5 m, or 69.1 µm.
Answer: (a) vs ≈ 8.99 mm/s, Re ≈ 0.90 — Stokes applies. (b) Minimum diameter for complete removal: 24.1 µm inorganic, 69.1 µm organic. Trap note: the organic particle needs to be nearly three times the diameter of the quartz particle to settle at the same speed, because the driving force is (S − 1) — 0.20 against 1.65 — and the diameter goes as the square root of that ratio. A candidate who uses S instead of (S − 1) gets the quartz diameter wrong by a factor of √(2.65/1.65) and the organic diameter wrong by a factor of √(1.20/0.20) — nearly two and a half times. The second trap is skipping the Reynolds check: at 0.10 mm the particle is right at the edge of the Stokes regime, and a 1.0 mm sand grain run through the same formula would give Re near 900, where the Stokes answer is fiction.
Worked problem 4 The settle-before-the-outlet check (PE pace, US units)
Given: a sedimentation basin is 100 ft long, 50 ft wide and 10 ft deep, and treats 6.0 MGD. The outlet weirs total 250 ft. Find the surface overflow rate, the detention time, the horizontal flow velocity, and the weir loading — and judge whether the target particle (settling velocity equal to the overflow rate) clears the basin before reaching the outlet.
Solution:
- Plan area: A = 100 × 50 = 5,000 ft². Surface overflow rate: SOR = 6,000,000 ÷ 5,000 = 1,200 gpd/ft² — at the top of the typical 800–1,200 gpd/ft² range.
- Volume: V = 100 × 50 × 10 = 50,000 ft³ × 7.48 = 374,000 gal (0.374 MG). Detention time: t = 0.374 ÷ 6.0 × 24 = 1.50 h — below the typical 2–4 h range, and short for flocculent settling.
- Horizontal velocity: the flow in ft³/day is 6,000,000 ÷ 7.48 = 802,100 ft³/day, and the cross-section is 50 × 10 = 500 ft², so vh = 802,100 ÷ 500 = 1,604 ft/day (0.0186 ft/s).
- The target particle settles at the overflow rate, 1,200 ft/day, so it falls the 10 ft depth in 10 ÷ 1,200 = 0.00833 day = 12.0 min, while the water takes 100 ÷ 1,604 = 0.0623 day = 89.8 min to travel the basin length — the particle clears with a seven-fold margin.
- Weir loading: 6,000,000 ÷ 250 = 24,000 gpd/ft — above the typical 10,000–20,000 gpd/ft range.
Answer: SOR = 1,200 gpd/ft²; detention 1.50 h; horizontal velocity 1,604 ft/day; the target particle settles in 12.0 min against a 89.8 min transit — it clears. But the weir loading of 24,000 gpd/ft and the short detention time say the basin is undersized at this flow: add a second basin or lengthen the weirs. Trap note: the settling check passes and the design still fails — the exam’s favourite verdict. A candidate who stops at the SOR (1,200 gpd/ft², just inside the range) and the settle-before-outlet margin misses both failing checks, and the weir loading is the one that matters operationally: water leaving at 24,000 gpd/ft scours settled sludge back over the weirs, so the basin removes the particles and then re-entrains them. The second trap is the horizontal velocity itself: it is Q divided by the cross-section (width × depth), not by the plan area — dividing by the plan area gives the overflow rate again, wearing the wrong label.
Worked problem 5 Sizing a basin from a design SOR (FE pace, SI)
Given: a water treatment plant must treat 15,000 m³/day. The design surface overflow rate is 20 m/day. Size a rectangular basin (choose the plan dimensions), find its detention time at a depth of 3.5 m, and check the weir loading if the outlet weirs total 115 m.
Solution:
- Area required: A = Q / v0 = 15,000 ÷ 20 = 750 m². Choose a 50 m × 15 m basin (750 m²), a length-to-width ratio of about 3.3 to 1, which keeps the horizontal velocity low and the flow uniform.
- Volume: V = 50 × 15 × 3.5 = 2,625 m³. Detention time: t = V / Q = 2,625 ÷ 15,000 = 0.175 day × 24 = 4.2 h — at the top of the typical 2–4 h range, comfortable for flocculent settling.
- Weir loading: 15,000 m³/day ÷ 115 m = 130 m³/m/day — about 10,500 gpd/ft, at the bottom of the typical 10,000–20,000 gpd/ft range.
Answer: a 50 m × 15 m × 3.5 m basin (750 m²); detention time ≈ 4.2 h; weir loading ≈ 130 m³/m/day — all three checks pass. Trap note: the sizing runs backwards from the overflow rate — the area is the flow divided by the design SOR, not multiplied by it, and a candidate who multiplies gets 300,000 m², a basin the size of a small town. The second trap is the depth: the depth never enters the overflow-rate calculation, only the detention time — a deeper basin at the same plan area has the same SOR and a longer detention time, which is why the exam gives the depth only when the detention time is being asked.
Frequently asked questions
What is the surface overflow rate in sedimentation?
The surface overflow rate (SOR), also called the surface loading rate, is the flow divided by the basin's plan area: SOR = Q / A. It has the units of a velocity (gpd/ft2 in US units, m/day in SI), and it is the settling velocity a particle needs to be removed completely: any particle whose settling velocity exceeds the SOR settles out before the water reaches the outlet weir. Water-treatment sedimentation basins typically run about 800-1,200 gpd/ft2; primary clarifiers about 600-1,200 gpd/ft2. Worked Problem 1 runs the calculation in US units, and Worked Problem 5 sizes a basin from a design SOR in SI.
How do you calculate the removal efficiency of a sedimentation basin?
For discrete (Type I) settling in an ideal basin, a particle with settling velocity vs is removed in proportion vs / v0, where v0 is the surface overflow rate — and any particle with vs at or above v0 is removed completely. So the removal efficiency is eta = vs / v0 x 100% for vs below v0, and 100% for vs at or above v0. The same ratio answers the sizing question backwards: the area a basin needs is A = Q / vs for the smallest particle to be removed completely. Worked Problem 2 runs the efficiency calculation, and Worked Problem 3 finds the smallest diameter removed completely at a given SOR.
When does Stokes' law apply to a settling particle?
Stokes' law, vs = g(S - 1)d2 / (18 nu), gives the terminal settling velocity of a small spherical particle in laminar flow — formally a particle Reynolds number Re = vs x d / nu below about 1, which in water at 20 °C means diameters below roughly 0.1 mm, silt and clay territory. Above that, the flow around the particle is no longer creeping and the real settling velocity falls below the Stokes value; coarse sand needs Newton's drag law instead. The exam tests the check, not just the formula: compute vs from Stokes, then compute Re, and only trust the answer if Re is below about 1. Worked Problem 3 runs the full check.
Detention time vs weir loading — what does each one check?
Detention time, t = V / Q, is how long the water stays in the basin — it uses the volume, and water-treatment basins typically run about 2-4 hours. Weir loading, Q divided by the total weir length, is how fast water leaves over the outlet weirs — it uses the weir length, and primary clarifiers typically run about 10,000-20,000 gpd/ft; a weir loading that is too high scours settled sludge back over the weirs. The surface overflow rate uses the plan area. The three checks use three different basin dimensions — area, volume, weir length — and swapping them is the standard basin-arithmetic error. Worked Problems 1 and 4 run all three checks on the same basin.
Why does cold water settle more slowly in a sedimentation basin?
Because Stokes' settling velocity is inversely proportional to the water's kinematic viscosity, and cold water is more viscous: at 5 °C the kinematic viscosity of water is about 1.52 x 10-6 m2/s against about 1.00 x 10-6 m2/s at 20 °C, so a particle settles about 34% more slowly in winter water than in summer water at the same temperature-corrected design. A basin sized for summer conditions removes finer particles in summer than in winter, which is why the exam's temperature-correction variants give the viscosity (or the temperature, so the candidate looks it up) and expect the settling velocity to change. The same viscosity effect is why the FE reference handbook carries the temperature table.
What surface overflow rate is normal for a water-treatment sedimentation basin?
Water-treatment sedimentation basins typically run a surface overflow rate of about 800-1,200 gpd/ft2 (about 33-49 m/day), and primary clarifiers about 600-1,200 gpd/ft2. These ranges are the exam's sanity check: a computed SOR of 5,000 gpd/ft2 means a unit error — usually the flow in gallons per day divided by an area in square feet without converting MGD, or the plan area replaced by the volume. Every worked problem on this page ends inside the normal ranges, and the traps list names the slips that push the answer outside them.
Free FE/PE flashcards + study tips, by email
Join the Water Resources Hub email list and get the free 40 water-resources flashcards (PDF + Anki) straight away, then study tips and practice problems by email. Email address only — no spam, unsubscribe any time.