Theory explainer
Consolidation Settlement Problems — FE/PE Civil Exam Worked Examples
Consolidation is the geotechnical question that always arrives in two parts: how much will the clay settle, and how long will it take? The first part is a straight line on a log plot — the e–log p curve — and the second is a single dimensionless number, the time factor. Learn both, plus the overconsolidated two-branch correction and the secondary-compression tail, and the whole family (normally consolidated, overconsolidated, lab-to-field, SI and US) collapses to a few lines each.
Last reviewed: 2026-11-06. Every worked number below was independently re-solved; steps are shown in full.
What consolidation is: three components of settlement
Total settlement of a loaded foundation has three parts, and the exam tests whether you can tell them apart. Immediate (elastic) settlement happens as the load is applied — compression of gas bubbles and elastic straining of the soil skeleton, over in minutes to days, mostly in sands and stiff clays. Primary consolidation is the slow one: a saturated clay loaded by a fill or a footing first hands the extra stress to its pore water (excess pore pressure), then the water drains out over months or years and the skeleton compresses as it takes the load. That time-dependent volume change is what this page is about. Secondary compression is the creep tail: the skeleton keeps rearranging slowly under constant effective stress after the pore pressures have fully dissipated, and it matters most in organic clays and peats. The amount of primary settlement comes from the e–log p curve; the rate comes from the time factor; the secondary tail has its own log-time equation. Keep the three separate and the problems stay short.
The e–log p curve: Cc, Cr, and the preconsolidation pressure
Everything about the amount of consolidation settlement lives on one graph: void ratio e against log10 of vertical effective stress, measured in the oedometer (one-dimensional consolidation) test. A clay loaded for the first time follows the virgin compression line, whose slope is the compression index Cc = −Δe/Δlog10σ′. If the clay is unloaded and reloaded, it follows a much flatter recompression line with slope Cr — typically one-fifth to one-tenth of Cc. The kink where the recompression line meets the virgin line is the preconsolidation pressure σ′c, the greatest effective stress the clay has ever carried, found by Casagrande’s construction. The overconsolidation ratio OCR = σ′c/σ′v0 summarises the stress history: OCR = 1 is normally consolidated, OCR > 1 is overconsolidated. A clay can be overconsolidated because a glacier once sat on it, because metres of soil were eroded away, or because a previous structure was removed — the exam gives you σ′c or OCR directly, so you never have to guess the geology.
The settlement itself is a void-ratio change converted to a thickness change: sc = H0 · Δe/(1 + e0), where Δe is read off the e–log p curve for the stress increment. When the stem gives you e0 and ef directly, that form is the fastest route — Worked Problem 1 uses the Cc form, but the Δe form is the same equation with one step skipped. For a thick layer, split it into sublayers and use the midpoint stress of each; a single midpoint stress is the exam’s usual approximation for a layer up to about 10 ft (3 m) thick.
Normally vs overconsolidated: the two-branch equation
For a normally consolidated clay (OCR = 1), the whole stress increment rides the virgin line: sc = [H0/(1 + e0)] · Cc · log10[( σ′v0 + Δσ)/σ′v0]. For an overconsolidated clay where the final stress stays below the preconsolidation pressure (σ′v0 + Δσ ≤ σ′c), the whole increment rides the recompression line instead — same equation with Cr in place of Cc. The interesting case, and the one the exam reaches for, is the split: the final stress crosses the preconsolidation pressure, so the increment is two branches — Cr from σ′v0 up to σ′c, then Cc from σ′c to the final stress: sc = [H0/(1 + e0)] · [Cr · log10(σ′c/σ′v0) + Cc · log10((σ′v0 + Δσ)/σ′c)]. Worked Problem 2 runs the split and shows what the normally-consolidated assumption would have cost: 6.65 in instead of the true 2.59 in.
Time rate: the time factor and the drainage path
The amount of settlement is only half the question; the other half is when. Terzaghi’s one-dimensional consolidation theory reduces the rate to a single dimensionless number, the time factor Tv = cv · t / Hdr², where cv is the coefficient of consolidation (from the oedometer test, units of area per time) and Hdr is the longest drainage path. The average degree of consolidation U — the fraction of primary settlement complete — is a fixed function of Tv, and the exam reaches for two values above all: Tv = 0.197 at U = 50% and Tv = 0.848 at U = 90%. The useful approximations are Tv = (π/4)U² for U ≤ 60% and Tv = 1.781 − 0.933·log10(100 − U%) for U > 60%.
| Average degree of consolidation U | Time factor Tv | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| 50% | 0.197 | Half of primary settlement complete |
| 70% | 0.403 | Roughly two-thirds done; still draining noticeably |
| 90% | 0.848 | The usual design target — “most” of primary consolidation |
| 95% | 1.129 | Conservative target when post-construction settlement must be small |
| 99% | 1.781 | Effectively complete; the tail is asymptotic |
Two habits keep the time factor from biting you. First, time scales with Hdr², not Hdr — doubling the drainage path quadruples the time, and the lab-to-field jump in Worked Problem 3 (a 1-inch specimen to a 10-foot field layer) is a factor of 57,600 on the time. Second, Hdr is the longest path, not the layer thickness: a doubly drained layer drains from both faces, so Hdr is half the thickness; a singly drained layer (impermeable rock below, sand above) drains one way, so Hdr is the full thickness. Confusing the two makes the time answer wrong by a factor of four.
Secondary compression: the creep tail
When the excess pore pressure has fully dissipated (U = 100%), primary consolidation is over — but the soil keeps settling. Secondary compression is the skeleton rearranging under constant effective stress, and it runs on log time: ss = [H0/(1 + e0)] · Cα · log10(t2/t1), where Cα is the secondary compression index and t1 is the time primary consolidation ends. The clock starts at the end of primary consolidation, not at loading — a stem that asks for secondary settlement “between 2 and 20 years” has already told you t1 = 2 years. In ordinary clays Cα is small (roughly 0.01–0.02) and the tail adds an inch or so over a decade; in organic clays and peats Cα can be ten times larger and secondary settlement rivals primary. Worked Problem 4 runs the ordinary-clay case.
Worked problem 1 Primary settlement of a normally consolidated clay (FE pace, US units)
Given: a 12 ft thick saturated clay layer, normally consolidated, with e0 = 0.85 and Cc = 0.30. The initial vertical effective stress at the layer midpoint is σ′v0 = 1,800 psf, and a fill imposes an average Δσ = 900 psf. Find the primary consolidation settlement.
Solution:
- Normally consolidated, so the whole increment rides the virgin line: sc = [H0/(1 + e0)] · Cc · log10[( σ′v0 + Δσ)/σ′v0]
- Stress ratio: (1,800 + 900)/1,800 = 2,700/1,800 = 1.50; log10(1.50) = 0.1761
- sc = [12/(1 + 0.85)] × 0.30 × 0.1761 = 6.486 × 0.30 × 0.1761 = 0.343 ft
- Convert: 0.343 × 12 = 4.11 in
Answer: sc ≈ 4.11 in. Trap note: the stresses are effective stresses at the midpoint — if the stem gives you the water table, subtract the pore pressure first. And the log is base ten: using ln(1.50) = 0.4055 instead of 0.1761 would give 9.47 in, more than double the right answer.
Worked problem 2 Overconsolidated clay — the two-branch split (FE pace, US units)
Given: a 10 ft thick clay layer with e0 = 0.90, Cc = 0.35 and Cr = 0.06. The initial effective stress at the midpoint is σ′v0 = 1,500 psf, the preconsolidation pressure is σ′c = 2,500 psf (OCR = 1.67), and a structure adds Δσ = 1,500 psf. Find the primary consolidation settlement, and compare with the normally-consolidated assumption.
Solution:
- Final stress: σ′vf = 1,500 + 1,500 = 3,000 psf, which exceeds σ′c = 2,500 psf — the increment crosses the preconsolidation pressure, so it splits into two branches.
- Recompression branch (1,500 → 2,500 psf): Cr · log10(2,500/1,500) = 0.06 × log10(1.6667) = 0.06 × 0.2218 = 0.01331
- Virgin branch (2,500 → 3,000 psf): Cc · log10(3,000/2,500) = 0.35 × log10(1.20) = 0.35 × 0.07918 = 0.02771
- sc = [10/(1 + 0.90)] × (0.01331 + 0.02771) = 5.263 × 0.04102 = 0.216 ft = 2.59 in
- Had the clay been treated as normally consolidated: sc = 5.263 × 0.35 × log10(3,000/1,500) = 5.263 × 0.35 × 0.3010 = 0.554 ft = 6.65 in — 2.6 times the true value.
Answer: sc ≈ 2.59 in (versus 6.65 in if the overconsolidation is ignored). Trap note: the 6.65 in number is the bait — it is the answer you get by reaching for Cc before checking OCR. Always compare the final stress with the preconsolidation pressure before choosing a branch, and note how small the recompression contribution is: the first 1,000 psf of loading produces barely a third of the settlement of the last 500 psf.
Worked problem 3 Time rate — from a lab oedometer test to the field (PE pace, US units)
Given: a laboratory oedometer specimen 1 in thick, doubly drained, reaches 50% consolidation in t50 = 12 minutes. The field clay layer is 10 ft thick, singly drained (impermeable rock at the base, sand above), with the same cv. The total primary settlement is sc = 6.0 in. Find (a) the time to 50% consolidation in the field, (b) the time to 90%, and (c) the settlement after 1 year.
Solution:
- Drainage paths: lab Hdr,lab = 1 in/2 = 0.5 in (double drainage); field Hdr,field = 10 ft = 120 in (single drainage — the full thickness).
- Same cv and same U means the same Tv, so t scales with Hdr²: t50,field = 12 min × (120/0.5)² = 12 × 240² = 12 × 57,600 = 691,200 min = 480 days.
- Time to 90%: t90 = t50 × (Tv,90/Tv,50) = 480 × (0.848/0.197) = 480 × 4.305 = 2,066 days ≈ 5.66 years.
- Settlement after 1 year: cv = Tv,50 · Hdr,lab²/t50,lab = 0.197 × 0.5²/12 = 0.004104 in²/min. After 365 days (525,600 min), Tv = cv·t/Hdr,field² = 0.004104 × 525,600/120² = 0.1498. Since U < 60%, U = √(4Tv/π) = √(4 × 0.1498/π) = 0.437 — 43.7% of primary settlement complete.
- Settlement after 1 year: s = U · sc = 0.437 × 6.0 = 2.62 in of the 6.0 in total.
Answer: t50 ≈ 480 days, t90 ≈ 2,066 days (≈ 5.7 years), settlement after 1 year ≈ 2.62 in. Trap note: the scaling is quadratic in the drainage path — a 240-fold longer path is a 57,600-fold longer time, which is why a 12-minute lab test becomes a year-and-a-half in the field. The other classic slip is halving the field path: the rock base does not drain, so Hdr is the full 10 ft, and halving it would cut the time answer by a factor of four.
Worked problem 4 Secondary compression after primary ends (PE pace, US units)
Given: an 8 ft thick clay layer with e0 = 0.90 and secondary compression index Cα = 0.02. Primary consolidation is complete 2 years after loading. Find the secondary settlement between 2 years and 20 years after loading.
Solution:
- Secondary settlement runs on log time from the end of primary consolidation: ss = [H0/(1 + e0)] · Cα · log10(t2/t1), with t1 = 2 years and t2 = 20 years.
- log10(20/2) = log10(10) = 1.00 — one log cycle.
- ss = [8/(1 + 0.90)] × 0.02 × 1.00 = 4.211 × 0.02 = 0.0842 ft = 1.01 in.
Answer: ss ≈ 1.01 in between years 2 and 20. Trap note: the clock starts when primary consolidation ends (t1 = 2 years), not at loading — using t1 = 0 or t1 = 1 year inflates the log ratio. And the answer is per log cycle: the next tenfold stretch (20 to 200 years) adds the same 1.01 in again, which is why secondary settlement matters for structures with long design lives.
Worked problem 5 Settlement and time rate (SI units)
Given: a 5 m thick saturated clay layer, normally consolidated, doubly drained, with e0 = 0.95 and Cc = 0.32. The initial vertical effective stress at the midpoint is σ′v0 = 90 kPa, an embankment adds Δσ = 50 kPa, and the coefficient of consolidation is cv = 4.0 m²/year. Find the primary consolidation settlement and the time to 90% consolidation.
Solution:
- Settlement: sc = [5/(1 + 0.95)] × 0.32 × log10[(90 + 50)/90] = 2.564 × 0.32 × log10(1.5556) = 2.564 × 0.32 × 0.1919 = 0.157 m = 157 mm.
- Drainage path: double drainage, so Hdr = 5/2 = 2.5 m.
- Time to 90%: t90 = Tv,90 · Hdr²/cv = 0.848 × 2.5²/4.0 = 0.848 × 6.25/4.0 = 1.32 years.
Answer: sc ≈ 157 mm; t90 ≈ 1.32 years. Trap note: kPa and kN/m² are the same unit, so the stress ratio is unit-free — but cv in m²/year demands Hdr in metres and gives t in years. Mixing cv in m²/s with a time answer in years is the unit slip the SI version of this problem is built around.
Frequently asked questions
What is consolidation settlement?
Consolidation settlement is the slow, time-dependent compression of a saturated clay as excess pore water pressure drains away after loading. The water initially carries the added stress; as it escapes, the soil skeleton takes the load and the layer shortens. It is the primary (long-term) component of total settlement, distinct from immediate elastic settlement and from secondary compression (creep) that continues after pore pressures have dissipated.
What is the difference between normally consolidated and overconsolidated clay?
A normally consolidated clay is carrying about the greatest effective stress it has ever carried, so any added load follows the steep virgin compression line with slope Cc. An overconsolidated clay once carried a larger stress (its preconsolidation pressure) and was then unloaded, so reloading up to that pressure follows the much flatter recompression line with slope Cr. Using Cc on an overconsolidated clay overstates settlement by a factor of several — Worked Problem 2 shows a 2.6-fold overestimate.
How long does consolidation take?
The time to a given degree of consolidation comes from the time factor Tv = cv · t/Hdr², where cv is the coefficient of consolidation and Hdr is the longest drainage path. Tv = 0.197 marks 50% consolidation and Tv = 0.848 marks 90%. Time scales with the square of the drainage path, so a field layer ten times thicker than the lab specimen takes roughly a hundred times longer to reach the same degree of consolidation — Worked Problem 3 shows a 12-minute lab test becoming 480 days in the field.
What is the drainage path, and why does it matter?
The drainage path Hdr is the longest distance pore water must travel to escape the clay layer. If the clay drains from both top and bottom (double drainage, e.g. sand layers above and below), Hdr is half the layer thickness; if it drains from one side only (single drainage, e.g. an impermeable rock base), Hdr is the full thickness. Because time scales with Hdr squared, mistaking single for double drainage makes the time answer wrong by a factor of four.
What is secondary compression?
Secondary compression is the slow creep of the soil skeleton under constant effective stress, after primary consolidation is complete and excess pore pressures have dissipated. It is computed as ss = [H0/(1 + e0)] · Cα · log10(t2/t1), where t1 is the time primary consolidation ends and t2 is the later time of interest. It matters most in organic clays and peats, where it can rival primary settlement; in ordinary clays it is usually a small correction.
Why does the consolidation equation use log base ten?
The compression index Cc is defined as the slope of the void-ratio versus log-base-ten effective stress curve from the oedometer test, so the settlement equation uses log10 by construction. Using the natural log instead inflates the answer by a factor of ln(10) = 2.303 — the single most common arithmetic trap on this topic.
Free FE/PE flashcards + study tips, by email
Join the Water Resources Hub email list and get the free 40 water-resources flashcards (PDF + Anki) straight away, then study tips and practice problems by email. Email address only — no spam, unsubscribe any time.